Western Live Action Anime Adaptions

Husky_Khan

The Dog Whistler... I mean Whisperer.
Founder
I know, finally a thread to celebrate all of the excellent live action adaptions of Anime that have been brought to the small screen, often courtesy of Netflix.

See that new Cowboy Bebop trailer?

Here you go!



It's already apparently far more well received (though perhaps not saying much) then the rather creative but ultimately not very Bebopish (is that a word?) teaser trailer released a week ago that the Internet universally... reacted to.

 

Val the Moofia Boss

Well-known member
The Rurouni Kenshin movies were good. Would recommend even if you've never seen the anime adaptation (which was also good) or read the manga. Watch order is pretty straight forward: movie 1 > 2 > 3. If you want to watch the anime, you just watch the first 61 episodes. After episode 31, you can watch the Trust and Betrayal OVA.

E633sy3.png
 

prinCZess

Warrior, Writer, Performer, Perv
Western Live Action Anime Adaptions
Whenever I see this type of phrase, my mind inevitably goes to a certain project that was...universally panned as basically terrible. And I never saw it, but based upon reputation and commentary heard from people who did subject themselves to it, not seeing it was definitely the right decision.

iu

DRAGONBALL EVOLUTION

Ironically, and to some degree arguable since it's based off something else and just had diverging adaptations as anime and western live-action, so may not count, the one 'successful' instance that occurs to me off the top of my head is also a cheese-fest, but...OF COURSE it has to be mentioned:
iu

I have also heard good things about 'SpeedRacer'. Not 'good' in terms of it being a 'good' movie, but...'good' in a somewhat Bruce Campbell-y B-movie but also labor-of-love and such ways...Never seen it myself yet, but that's one that bears mention (even if SpeedRacer is...decades old? Was that 60s? 70s? I dunnow and am too lazy to search it).

See that new Cowboy Bebop trailer?
Well, I have now.

...*sigh* I dunnow. The trailer makes it look better than the teaser thingy or the the intro--both of which kind've made it look like a porn-parody. That said, I'm only mildly piqued by the trailer and the first rule of media is that trailers are filthy lying buttheads in terms of presenting any picture of what anything will actually be like. I don't really believe or expect Netflix to do a good job, and they'd have to do a really good one to escape past how much the costuming and casting does kind'a feel/look to me like it's decidedly budget and B-grade.

Certainly won't be paying money to Netflix to watch, and probably won't bother unless the net goes crazy with skeptics who are also profoundly surprised at a job well-done.
 

Captain X

Well-known member
Osaul
They also made the palest character in Death Note black. And speaking of, Jet Black's name is literal, apparently. ;)

Personally, I'm doing my best to just ignore this completely unnecessary "adaptation."
 

Terthna

Professional Lurker
They also made the palest character in Death Note black. And speaking of, Jet Black's name is literal, apparently. ;)

Personally, I'm doing my best to just ignore this completely unnecessary "adaptation."
Every live-action adaptation of an origionally animated IP is completely unnecessary, in my opinion at least. It's somewhat justifiable if the anime itself was also an adaptation, of like a manga or a light novel, but wanting to adapt something that has been animated and grown popular into live-action, always seems to be rooted in the belief that animation is somehow a lesser artform; and I find that reasoning to be incredibly arrogant and narrowminded.
 

Husky_Khan

The Dog Whistler... I mean Whisperer.
Founder
I will say I did enjoy the Netflix movie of Death Note though I'm sure that was in large part exactly due to the fact I never read the manga or other original source material. 😨
 

Bear Ribs

Well-known member
Whenever I see this type of phrase, my mind inevitably goes to a certain project that was...universally panned as basically terrible. And I never saw it, but based upon reputation and commentary heard from people who did subject themselves to it, not seeing it was definitely the right decision.

iu

DRAGONBALL EVOLUTION

Ironically, and to some degree arguable since it's based off something else and just had diverging adaptations as anime and western live-action, so may not count, the one 'successful' instance that occurs to me off the top of my head is also a cheese-fest, but...OF COURSE it has to be mentioned:
iu

I have also heard good things about 'SpeedRacer'. Not 'good' in terms of it being a 'good' movie, but...'good' in a somewhat Bruce Campbell-y B-movie but also labor-of-love and such ways...Never seen it myself yet, but that's one that bears mention (even if SpeedRacer is...decades old? Was that 60s? 70s? I dunnow and am too lazy to search it).


Well, I have now.

...*sigh* I dunnow. The trailer makes it look better than the teaser thingy or the the intro--both of which kind've made it look like a porn-parody. That said, I'm only mildly piqued by the trailer and the first rule of media is that trailers are filthy lying buttheads in terms of presenting any picture of what anything will actually be like. I don't really believe or expect Netflix to do a good job, and they'd have to do a really good one to escape past how much the costuming and casting does kind'a feel/look to me like it's decidedly budget and B-grade.

Certainly won't be paying money to Netflix to watch, and probably won't bother unless the net goes crazy with skeptics who are also profoundly surprised at a job well-done.
I've seen Dragonball: Evolution. I honestly didn't think it was as bad as all that. Yeah, it's a bizarrely low-power version of early Dragonball and it cuts about 90% of everything out, but they did have to make a sprawling story that took 100,000 years of real-time footage just for a guy to clench into an hour and a half. That said the special effects were awful, and Kid Goku's story really, really doesn't work with a teenager protagonist.

For most terrible Imma nominate Street Fighter: Legend of Chun-Li.

Legend_of_chun_li.jpg


Chun-Li is degraded from badass Interpol police officer to a concert pianist. She can't fight and appears to have taken a minor in pole-dancing instead. Balrog uses a rocket launcher, guns, anything to avoid having to ever throw a punch and Vega appears to have an outfit lower in quality than a Dollar General Halloween costume. Nobody wears anything like their iconic outfits, of course, and the chaser is that Bison is no longer a brutal warlord but an Irish real estate developer who sounds like the Lucky Charms mascot. Oh yeah, and rather than use any of her iconic moves, Chun-Li spontaneously figures out how to use the Hadoken after throwing sand in Bison's face because that's obviously vintage Chun-Li right there.

Speed Racer I found to be quite fun. It's nonsensical and silly to the extreme but it gets by anyway by embracing the silliness and craziness of the setting, and instead of apologizing it cranks everything to 11 on the crazy-ometer. When a dude flips his car so he can punch a guy in the mouth who's car he's flipping over you know the crazy train ain't ending soon.
 

prinCZess

Warrior, Writer, Performer, Perv
Honestly, I expected that move in one of the 312 Fast and Furious movies.
...And now I'm picturing the inverse of 'Western live-action anime adaptation' where Fast & Furious is adapted into an anime. I...don't actually think very many changes would result. Cheese-fest dialogue? Works. Same focus on action and excuse-plot? Seems appropriate to many animes. Same over-the-top bullshit action? Yehhhp.

Though I suppose Dominique Torreto and his pec-exposing wife-beaters would probably become Dominique Toretto and her D-cup revealing tank-top.
 

Husky_Khan

The Dog Whistler... I mean Whisperer.
Founder
This is sarcasm, right?

Nice job you guys... you killed our best chance at getting a live action adaption of Cowboy Bebop!


Now we'll never see Cowboy Bebop how it was truly meant to be enjoyed... in glorious live action and free of the main characters Jewishness.
 
Last edited:

The Immortal Watch Dog

Well-known member
Hetman
Nice job you guys... you killed our best chance at getting a live action adaption of Cowboy Bebop!


Now we'll never see Cowboy Bebop how it was truly meant to be enjoyed... in glorious live action and free of the main characters Jewishness.

The Reeves project sounds like it would be great...plus he would honor the source material. This nonsense though? May it be purged from memory.
 

Captain X

Well-known member
Osaul
Nice job you guys... you killed our best chance at getting a live action adaption of Cowboy Bebop!


Now we'll never see Cowboy Bebop how it was truly meant to be enjoyed... in glorious live action and free of the main characters Jewishness.
grumpy-cat-good.jpg
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top