Alternate History What If? “Monsterization” from Monster Girl Encyclopedia became a “disease” IRL?

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
For anybody who doesn’t know what Monster Girl Encyclopedia is

It’s basically a porn setting wherein once, monsters were made to constantly commit mass genocide on humans before humans got “heroes” to turn back the tide. Rinse and Repeat, by their “Chief God”.

A Succubus became the Demon Lord and turned all of the monsters into part-succubi who love human men(who could become incubi)and have the ability to turn human women into monstergirls as well

So, what if, this “Monsterization” became a “disease” IRL with no idea by scientists as to where it came from, much less a way to cure it and the results of each Monsterization are nearly random

Like a female athlete heavy weightlifter becoming a Kikimora. A monstergirl that’s some sort of dogbird maid girl who does cooking and cleaning.

All while still remembering their times as humans and behaving as such with minor modifications or ticks
 

bullethead

Part-time fanfic writer
Super Moderator
Staff Member
Probably would help if your OP wasn't so vague that it comes off as more suited for SF & Fantasy Discussion. The title doesn't help either.

That said, from my understanding of MGE, the example of monsterization you posted in your OP wouldn't happen. It generally seems to be a "you turn into the same species that turned you," turn into a generic succubus, or "get turned into something related to some aspect of your personality" thing.
 

bullethead

Part-time fanfic writer
Super Moderator
Staff Member
Well, now that the issue of where the thread belongs has been sorted by those higher up in the chain, here's my assessment of this vaguely constructed thought experiment.

First, I am assuming this "What if" takes place in our reality, meaning monster girls in general and MGE in particular are known by people.

Second, I am going with a best case scenario where this "disease" only affects women in between the ages of 15-40, and assuming random affliction.

Third, I am presuming that monsterization produces monster girls without the conflicting "mate with humans" and "attack humans" drives that canon MGE monster girls have.

Fourth, I will assume that none of the super magic heavy and undead monster girls are being produced.

This leads to two basic potential outcomes, based on initial distribution. Let's call these Forecast A and Forecast B.

Forecast A calls for a small initial number of afflictees, with a slow, steady increase as time progresses, with widespread global distribution. World health organizations and governments try to figure this thing out and fail hard, especially if the monsterization is totally different on a person by person basis. Lots of conspiracy theories will spread, because this is some Resident Evil shit given the whole "biomass out of nowhere" thing, but no one will find a definitive cause.

The various religions will have to deal with the ramifications of this, particularly the Abrahamic faiths. The Middle East and much of the Third World are unlikely to react well to it, and it's likely that the monster girls there that manage to avoid getting killed will flee to Europe and other countries. I suspect most of the Christian denominations will eventually come around to accepting them as long as they worship God and obey the commandments, etc...

There will be a lot of persistent long term problems as we have to sort out things like legal stances on polyamory (because good luck convincing two women who probably possess super strength who're okay with that that they can't do it), OHSA standards for women of wildly varying bodyforms, and all the other shit that affects day to day life. Politically, there'll probably be demographic and party realignments due to the weird mix of liberal and conservative ideals that MGE is full of. Shinzo Abe will finally get more Japanese people making babies though, although I wouldn't be surprised if there's a strong pushback against Japanese work culture and laws by monster girls.

Forecast A can basically be summed up as short and medium term upheaval and uncertainty, followed by (hopefully) long-term stabilization as a new status quo is achieved.

Forecast B calls for widespread, high numbers of initial monsterization cases. Everyone will be thinking either "bioweapon attack" or "end of the world demon shit", and the MGE fans will be freaking out and wondering if the more radical MGE factions are behind it. High probability that everyday life will come to a grinding halt, as people hunker down and the governments try to figure this out.

The Middle East and Third World will become an ocean of blood, and it's highly possible that violence just happens everywhere as people do what they think is best to survive the craziness. Things might be so bad that some countries/regions go entropic and collapse entirely. Overall, we're looking at massive disruption to society, on a never before seen level.

Assuming that governments manage to survive, things will be fucked for a while, and whether or not everything goes to shit and into full-fledged apocalypse depends on too many variables to even comprehend.
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
@bullethead
OSHA Laws, now that I think about it, lots of ladies would be out of a job and not be allowed so much movement on the basis that they can’t even fit through the door, they’ll take up huge amounts of space on a bus or plane, giant paw hands aren’t good for writing and typing

Also clothes, how are they going to properly put on clothes with those arms and legs or lack of them

In-Regards to Third World and Muslim Nations, gonna have to bet that the latter coming over may receive even more “apprehension” on the basis that they automatically discriminate against the “demon whores” who may not even be allowed to live. Might at least allow them to live but with bigger veils.
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
I don’t understand the relevance of your question. If they are infected, purge them. Humanity must survive. We must survive.

Ever read Isaac Asimov’s Robots/Galactic Empire/Foundation series?

“Humanity” as a concept can be stretched

It’s why in the last Foundation book and the in the last Robots book, the Solarian Robots were willing and able to kill robots whilst still working within the Three Laws of Robotics

To them in Foundation, “humans” were adult Solarians(a highly genetically modified version of humanity that had both sexes and centuries long lifespans and psychic abilities) while in Robots, “humans” were Solarians and spoke in the Solarian accent

__alraune_and_automaton_monster_girl_encyclopedia_drawn_by_latenight__786335d9501cfd63864b2f2a564364c8.jpg


This too is “human”, even Foundations R. Daneel Olivaw and Giscard, both robots managed to think themselves to a degree “human”
 

PsihoKekec

Swashbuckling Accountant
They are baqsically xenos and thou shall not suffer xeno to live. But seriously, newly made monsters would be quarantined if they behave in civilized manner and put down with extreme prejudice if they don't. That is if we lived in rational society, which we don't. Some governments will overreact, while others will underreact. There will be explosion of religius extremism, ranging from shunning of the newly made monsters to outright pogroms. There will be killings for organs, to be used as alternate medicines, charms or mutis. There will be fetishisation and cults dedicated to veneration and protection of these monsters. There will be chaos and bloodshed.
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
They are baqsically xenos and thou shall not suffer xeno to live. But seriously, newly made monsters would be quarantined if they behave in civilized manner and put down with extreme prejudice if they don't. That is if we lived in rational society, which we don't. Some governments will overreact, while others will underreact. There will be explosion of religius extremism, ranging from shunning of the newly made monsters to outright pogroms. There will be killings for organs, to be used as alternate medicines, charms or mutis. There will be fetishisation and cults dedicated to veneration and protection of these monsters. There will be chaos and bloodshed.

There will also be people, especially women, envious of their restored youth and beauty

If they find it’s transmittable....well safer than plastic surgery

This will set back social values in relation to women back, when they live with embodiments of the whole stuff to do with “unrealistic beauty standards”

Also, I’d say Mutants instead of Aliens, because they’re all former baseline humans
 
Last edited:

DarthOne

☦️
Ever read Isaac Asimov’s Robots/Galactic Empire/Foundation series?

“Humanity” as a concept can be stretched

It’s why in the last Foundation book and the in the last Robots book, the Solarian Robots were willing and able to kill robots whilst still working within the Three Laws of Robotics

To them in Foundation, “humans” were adult Solarians(a highly genetically modified version of humanity that had both sexes and centuries long lifespans and psychic abilities) while in Robots, “humans” were Solarians and spoke in the Solarian accent

__alraune_and_automaton_monster_girl_encyclopedia_drawn_by_latenight__786335d9501cfd63864b2f2a564364c8.jpg


This too is “human”, even Foundations R. Daneel Olivaw and Giscard, both robots managed to think themselves to a degree “human”
The issues I have is that these creatures are corrupted caricatures of their former human selves. And that they spread like a disease, transforming people against their will. Therefore, they are not only a threat to mankind’s continued existence and society and must be put down. But one that it is morally righteous to fight against.
 

bullethead

Part-time fanfic writer
Super Moderator
Staff Member
Honestly, if the monster girls come with the intended "male kids are human, female kids are monster girls" functionality, then they stop being an existential threat.

That said, the fact that the disease does fuck with the victim's personality to some degree is not great.
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
Honestly, if the monster girls come with the intended "male kids are human, female kids are monster girls" functionality, then they stop being an existential threat.

That said, the fact that the disease does fuck with the victim's personality to some degree is not great.

Male Kids are Human.....I think there’s gonna be another problem, I think Monstergirls live longer than humans and as far as I can tell don’t exactly look to grow wrinkled, weathered or ugly with age

Mayfly-December Romances aren’t something I think are mentally healthy
 

DarthOne

☦️
Honestly, if the monster girls come with the intended "male kids are human, female kids are monster girls" functionality, then they stop being an existential threat.

That said, the fact that the disease does fuck with the victim's personality to some degree is not great.
That's an understatement...

I really do feel that the only reason the monstergirls get so much sympathy is 'muh hot animu waifu'. When in fact they're just a more physically appealing and non-hivemind version of the Borg.
 

CarlManvers2019

Writers Blocked Douchebag
That's an understatement...

I really do feel that the only reason the monstergirls get so much sympathy is 'muh hot animu waifu'. When in fact they're just a more physically appealing and non-hivemind version of the Borg.

Well, I gotta say, I think acceptance of this ‘muh hot anime waifu’ virus would be a better alternative compared to say......well I think all my european comics will be banned according to the whims of a supposedly feminist religion, too much casual nudity
 

Doomsought

Well-known member
Honestly, if the monster girls come with the intended "male kids are human, female kids are monster girls" functionality, then they stop being an existential threat.
Even if they still produce male children, the personality types that are developed may still produce sociological collapse, there is a certain amount of trust, reason or apathy in the population that is needed to maintain advanced societies. Many of the personality templates, if not outright cannibalistic, are degenerate enough to reduce productivity and social order in their general vicinity.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top