Which world is worse? Remnant or Attack on Titan Earth?

Val the Moofia Boss

Well-known member
It depends.

Attack on Titan: heavily dependent on 1. where you live and 2. if you live during the events of the story.
  • If you live within the Paradis walls, life is just medieval Europe and you're fine (unless you live during the events of the story, in which case everyone outside the second wall will die and the people within the second and first walls will face heavy food rationing). However, after the events of the story you're probably going to be a first class citizen in the strongest nation in the world.
  • If you live outside the walls and you're not Eldian, then life is just 18th-19th century Europe and you're fine. Unless you live during the events of the story, in which case if you live within a few hundred miles of Paradis, you will almost certainly die during the final arc of the story. If you live far enough away from Paradis, life is going to really suck because the ending implies that Paradis is going to go Eldian Empire 2.0 and take over the world and everyone else is going to become a second class citizen, if that.

Remnant
  • Depends on whether or not "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" is applied consistently. If it is, then the next question is whether or not this applied retroactively. "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" simply cannot coexist with the society we see in the show, where you have televised events like tournaments where inevitably people are going to get depressed or infuriated that their team lost, which should draw a huge amount of Grimm from miles around and promptly end a lot of towns just like that. If you go into the world with this turned on, then you and society are totally unprepared and the vast majority of humanity will promptly die out. You are living in a zombie apocalypse and you're going to have to rebuild society from the ground up. Good luck.
  • If "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" is in fact applied retroactively, then Remnant's society will probably resemble Pandaria (from WoW which endured very similar conditions with the Sha, evil spirits that were also drawn and empowered by negative emotions) and probably be a pretty chill place to live. People will have adjusted their attitude to be patient, lackadaisical, and not be very materialistic, and the setting will remain very low tech, with most people being subsistence farmers/shepherds with only a handful of engineers being able to be supported. Settlements will be village sized, no larger than small towns. Large cities like Vale or Atlas cannot exist in this world. The Grimm will very rarely ever be a problem because most people will have been cultured to never do anything that will attract the Grimm. There will be a very, very small organization of Hunters (like the Shado-Pan) training "just in case" and on the lookout for the Grimm, but more than likely life as Hunter won't be anywhere near as exciting as depicted in the show or as your usual fantasy adventurer; it will just be boring because there will be hardly any Grimm. If you want a chill, comfy, peaceful life, go here.
  • If you go to the RWBY world, but "Grimm being attracted to negative emotions" hardly ever happens even though it should (like in the show), then you're biggest worries are living in places where the plot happens. Unless you plan on derailing the plot, stay away from Vale, Atlas, and Vacuo. You'll be safest in Mistral and Menagerie (even as a human you'll be really safe on the Faunas island). If you decide to live in a small town or a village, you had better hope that your place is defended by several good hunters, as it seems like a lot of villages fall to Grimm or are ravaged by bandits during the events of the show.

Pandaria-esque Remant (bliss) >>>>> show Remnant (cool) >> (nice world to live in threshold) >> Living in Paradis (or hundreds of miles away from Paradis) (not fun but liveable) >>> Living in Remnant if the Grimm were realistic (likely death) >>>>>>>>>> living within a few hundred miles of Paradis (certain death)
 
Last edited:

Zachowon

The Army Life for me! The POG life for me!
Founder
It depends.

Attack on Titan: heavily dependent on 1. where you live and 2. if you live during the events of the story.
  • If you live within the Paradis walls, life is just medieval Europe and you're fine (unless you live during the events of the story, in which case everyone outside the second wall will die and the people within the second and first walls will face heavy food rationing). However, after the events of the story you're probably going to be a first class citizen in the strongest nation in the world.
  • If you live outside the walls and you're not Eldian, then life is just 18th-19th century Europe and you're fine. Unless you live during the events of the story, in which case if you live within a few hundred miles of Paradis, you will almost certainly die during the final arc of the story. If you live far enough away from Paradis, life is going to really suck because the ending implies that Paradis is going to go Eldian Empire 2.0 and take over the world and everyone else is going to become a second class citizen, if that.

Remnant
  • Depends on whether or not "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" is applied consistently. If it is, then the next question is whether or not this applied retroactively. "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" simply cannot coexist with the society we see in the show, where you have televised events like tournaments where inevitably people are going to get depressed or infuriated that their team lost, which should draw a huge amount of Grimm from miles around and promptly end a lot of towns just like that. If you go into the world with this turned on, then you and society are totally unprepared and the vast majority of humanity will promptly die out. You are living in a zombie apocalypse and you're going to have to rebuild society from the ground up. Good luck.
  • If "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" is in fact applied retroactively, then Remnant's society will probably resemble Pandaria (from WoW which endured very similar conditions with the Sha, evil spirits that were also drawn and empowered by negative emotions) and probably be a pretty chill place to live. People will have adjusted their attitude to be patient, lackadaisical, and not be very materialistic, and the setting will remain very low tech, with most people being subsistence farmers/shepherds with only a handful of engineers being able to be supported. Settlements will be village sized, no larger than small towns. Large cities like Vale or Atlas cannot exist in this world. The Grimm will very rarely ever be a problem because most people will have been cultured to never do anything that will attract the Grimm. There will be a very, very small organization of Hunters (like the Shado-Pan) training "just in case" and on the lookout for the Grimm, but more than likely life as Hunter won't be anywhere near as exciting as depicted in the show or as your usual fantasy adventurer; it will just be boring because there will be hardly any Grimm. If you want a chill, comfy, peaceful life, go here.
  • If you go to the RWBY world, but "Grimm being attracted to negative emotions" hardly ever happens even though it should (like in the show), then you're biggest worries are living in places where the plot happens. Unless you plan on derailing the plot, stay away from Vale, Atlas, and Vacuo. You'll be safest in Mistral and Menagerie (even as a human you'll be really safe on the Faunas island). If you decide to live in a small town or a village, you had better hope that your place is defended by several good hunters, as it seems like a lot of villages fall to Grimm or are ravaged by bandits during the events of the show.

Pandaria-esque Remant (bliss) >>>>> show Remnant (cool) >> (nice world to live in threshold) >> Living in Paradis (or hundreds of miles away from Paradis) (not fun but liveable) >>> Living in Remnant if the Grimm were realistic (likely death) >>>>>>>>>> living within a few hundred miles of Paradis (certain death)
So, in the show major settlements and the like are protected so normal very day feelings don't really do much for the Grimm.
It is when you have massive amounts of negative emotion are they ever attracted.

Thiugh the attack on Atlas is a mixture of the two.
Salem directing then and hunting by negative emotion. Fear mainly in that scenario
 

Aldarion

Neoreactionary Monarchist
  • If you live outside the walls and you're not Eldian, then life is just 18th-19th century Europe and you're fine. Unless you live during the events of the story, in which case if you live within a few hundred miles of Paradis, you will almost certainly die during the final arc of the story. If you live far enough away from Paradis, life is going to really suck because the ending implies that Paradis is going to go Eldian Empire 2.0 and take over the world and everyone else is going to become a second class citizen, if that.

How? I was under impression that the power of the titans is gone, so Paradis is just another nation of a large number of them.
 

ParadiseLost

Well-known member
How? I was under impression that the power of the titans is gone, so Paradis is just another nation of a large number of them.

It was also implied that Eren Jaegers whole purpose in going on his genocide run was to try and heal racial tensions through the Code Geass method of world peace promotion.
 

Val the Moofia Boss

Well-known member

Zachowon

The Army Life for me! The POG life for me!
Founder

Arlos

Sad Monarchist
It depends.

Attack on Titan: heavily dependent on 1. where you live and 2. if you live during the events of the story.
  • If you live within the Paradis walls, life is just medieval Europe and you're fine (unless you live during the events of the story, in which case everyone outside the second wall will die and the people within the second and first walls will face heavy food rationing). However, after the events of the story you're probably going to be a first class citizen in the strongest nation in the world.
  • If you live outside the walls and you're not Eldian, then life is just 18th-19th century Europe and you're fine. Unless you live during the events of the story, in which case if you live within a few hundred miles of Paradis, you will almost certainly die during the final arc of the story. If you live far enough away from Paradis, life is going to really suck because the ending implies that Paradis is going to go Eldian Empire 2.0 and take over the world and everyone else is going to become a second class citizen, if that.

Remnant
  • Depends on whether or not "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" is applied consistently. If it is, then the next question is whether or not this applied retroactively. "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" simply cannot coexist with the society we see in the show, where you have televised events like tournaments where inevitably people are going to get depressed or infuriated that their team lost, which should draw a huge amount of Grimm from miles around and promptly end a lot of towns just like that. If you go into the world with this turned on, then you and society are totally unprepared and the vast majority of humanity will promptly die out. You are living in a zombie apocalypse and you're going to have to rebuild society from the ground up. Good luck.
  • If "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" is in fact applied retroactively, then Remnant's society will probably resemble Pandaria (from WoW which endured very similar conditions with the Sha, evil spirits that were also drawn and empowered by negative emotions) and probably be a pretty chill place to live. People will have adjusted their attitude to be patient, lackadaisical, and not be very materialistic, and the setting will remain very low tech, with most people being subsistence farmers/shepherds with only a handful of engineers being able to be supported. Settlements will be village sized, no larger than small towns. Large cities like Vale or Atlas cannot exist in this world. The Grimm will very rarely ever be a problem because most people will have been cultured to never do anything that will attract the Grimm. There will be a very, very small organization of Hunters (like the Shado-Pan) training "just in case" and on the lookout for the Grimm, but more than likely life as Hunter won't be anywhere near as exciting as depicted in the show or as your usual fantasy adventurer; it will just be boring because there will be hardly any Grimm. If you want a chill, comfy, peaceful life, go here.
  • If you go to the RWBY world, but "Grimm being attracted to negative emotions" hardly ever happens even though it should (like in the show), then you're biggest worries are living in places where the plot happens. Unless you plan on derailing the plot, stay away from Vale, Atlas, and Vacuo. You'll be safest in Mistral and Menagerie (even as a human you'll be really safe on the Faunas island). If you decide to live in a small town or a village, you had better hope that your place is defended by several good hunters, as it seems like a lot of villages fall to Grimm or are ravaged by bandits during the events of the show.

Pandaria-esque Remant (bliss) >>>>> show Remnant (cool) >> (nice world to live in threshold) >> Living in Paradis (or hundreds of miles away from Paradis) (not fun but liveable) >>> Living in Remnant if the Grimm were realistic (likely death) >>>>>>>>>> living within a few hundred miles of Paradis (certain death)
I believe you forgot living as an Eldian outside of Paradis.
 

ParadiseLost

Well-known member

Val the Moofia Boss

Well-known member
Wait, so is there another chapter after the one where Mikasa thanks Eren-possessing-a-bird for wrapping the scarf around her?

The bombing page was leaked from the final tankobon volume of the manga, which hasn't been published yet. It has a slightly extended epilogue in which
Mikasa buries Eren's head in Paradis, and it grows into a large tree (the tree you see in the foreground of the Paradis city being bombed). This tree is very similar to the tree in which Ymir found and gave her the original titan powers, so I suppose the insinuation is that history repeats.
 

Navarro

Well-known member
It depends.

Attack on Titan: heavily dependent on 1. where you live and 2. if you live during the events of the story.
  • If you live within the Paradis walls, life is just medieval Europe and you're fine (unless you live during the events of the story, in which case everyone outside the second wall will die and the people within the second and first walls will face heavy food rationing). However, after the events of the story you're probably going to be a first class citizen in the strongest nation in the world.
  • If you live outside the walls and you're not Eldian, then life is just 18th-19th century Europe and you're fine. Unless you live during the events of the story, in which case if you live within a few hundred miles of Paradis, you will almost certainly die during the final arc of the story. If you live far enough away from Paradis, life is going to really suck because the ending implies that Paradis is going to go Eldian Empire 2.0 and take over the world and everyone else is going to become a second class citizen, if that.

Remnant
  • Depends on whether or not "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" is applied consistently. If it is, then the next question is whether or not this applied retroactively. "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" simply cannot coexist with the society we see in the show, where you have televised events like tournaments where inevitably people are going to get depressed or infuriated that their team lost, which should draw a huge amount of Grimm from miles around and promptly end a lot of towns just like that. If you go into the world with this turned on, then you and society are totally unprepared and the vast majority of humanity will promptly die out. You are living in a zombie apocalypse and you're going to have to rebuild society from the ground up. Good luck.
  • If "Grimm are attracted to negative emotions" is in fact applied retroactively, then Remnant's society will probably resemble Pandaria (from WoW which endured very similar conditions with the Sha, evil spirits that were also drawn and empowered by negative emotions) and probably be a pretty chill place to live. People will have adjusted their attitude to be patient, lackadaisical, and not be very materialistic, and the setting will remain very low tech, with most people being subsistence farmers/shepherds with only a handful of engineers being able to be supported. Settlements will be village sized, no larger than small towns. Large cities like Vale or Atlas cannot exist in this world. The Grimm will very rarely ever be a problem because most people will have been cultured to never do anything that will attract the Grimm. There will be a very, very small organization of Hunters (like the Shado-Pan) training "just in case" and on the lookout for the Grimm, but more than likely life as Hunter won't be anywhere near as exciting as depicted in the show or as your usual fantasy adventurer; it will just be boring because there will be hardly any Grimm. If you want a chill, comfy, peaceful life, go here.
  • If you go to the RWBY world, but "Grimm being attracted to negative emotions" hardly ever happens even though it should (like in the show), then you're biggest worries are living in places where the plot happens. Unless you plan on derailing the plot, stay away from Vale, Atlas, and Vacuo. You'll be safest in Mistral and Menagerie (even as a human you'll be really safe on the Faunas island). If you decide to live in a small town or a village, you had better hope that your place is defended by several good hunters, as it seems like a lot of villages fall to Grimm or are ravaged by bandits during the events of the show.

Pandaria-esque Remant (bliss) >>>>> show Remnant (cool) >> (nice world to live in threshold) >> Living in Paradis (or hundreds of miles away from Paradis) (not fun but liveable) >>> Living in Remnant if the Grimm were realistic (likely death) >>>>>>>>>> living within a few hundred miles of Paradis (certain death)

When World of Warcraft literally has more coherent and sensical worldbuilding than your setting.
 

Zachowon

The Army Life for me! The POG life for me!
Founder
When World of Warcraft literally has more coherent and sensical worldbuilding than your setting.
Eh, in RWBY some things take back seats. But in general the negative emotions has remained the same. It is a matter of how much compared to any at all.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top