Dune part 2
- Thread starter Typhonis
- Start date
Seems as good as part 1,but we will see.
They could made all fremen black lgbt jewish muslim dwarf-elved hybrids,after all !
Jokes aside - i missed Saudarkar singing here.
Skallagrim
Well-known member
Definitely my "most anticipated film" for this year. I really hope it doesn't let us down.
The same.I watched 1984 version and later series,both were inferior.
Pity,that Jodorowski do not gather enough money for his movie.It would be probably disaster,but glorious one !
I finally watched Dune part two.Good,solid movie,better then 1984 version or serial.
But,still made small mistakes,like turning Feud from backstabing psycho into kinda honorable psycho,made chani leave Paul,and start jihad becouse great Houses do not bow to Paul here.
And why leave one Fremen woman to get burned by Feud.
But,most important - WHY THEY INVENTED SOME FUNDAMENTALIST THERE? All Fremens in book was beliver,they only doubt if Paul is right Mahdi,or should they still wait.
When in movie they created some secular Fremen,which in book never existed.Modern world,i think.
But,still made small mistakes,like turning Feud from backstabing psycho into kinda honorable psycho,made chani leave Paul,and start jihad becouse great Houses do not bow to Paul here.
And why leave one Fremen woman to get burned by Feud.
But,most important - WHY THEY INVENTED SOME FUNDAMENTALIST THERE? All Fremens in book was beliver,they only doubt if Paul is right Mahdi,or should they still wait.
When in movie they created some secular Fremen,which in book never existed.Modern world,i think.
TheRejectionist
TheRejectionist
First movie was like "Yeah looks extremely well, acting is decent, but it feels a tad bit soulless".
True,but in book people like those still do not existed.They all take their prophecy seriously,only doubted if Paul is right one or not.
Another problem - why they let Hatkonnen defeat them and chase out of their sietch? in book it never happened.
There was no reason for making Harkonnen competent there.
And other High Lords wanting to fight Paul after he wiped out Saudarkars in one day - that do not have sense,too.
Yep, it's the pivotal lever Paul uses against the Emperor.
Indeed,but here with atomic arsenal of House Atredis,not using dead water from killed worms.
Dunno why,introducing Navigators would have more sense.
Another movie mistake - they do not even mentioned Navigators.
True,but their power was never mentioned.In book Paul threthened them after destroing Saudarkars,and Guild made other Noble Houses retreat.Here,they do not existed as political player.
Well,they looked more like tsar army commanders to me.And, it is pity that Jodorowsky do not made Dune - i really want to see his version of Emperor....
Make Space Prussia great again.
Those weren't the Navigators, those were just Spacing Guild people. The Navigators looked suitably alien and whatnot in the brief display of them.
I really loved that SciFi Channel Dune Miniseries. It's aged terribly since but I actually loved how they went overboard with the costumes, including the Spacing Guild and Sardaukar. As adaptions go and considering the low budget, it was actually pretty good adaption despite being so dated now.