Search results

Well, add. Heresy, I can see the extent of it every day. All I have to do is turn on my Twitter. The recent synod in the Czech Republic, for example, was so cathartic it's a pity for words. English instead of Latin as the universal language used at Mass, despite the fact that Latin is the...

Which, of course, is a heavily black and exaggerated scenario. Sooner there will be another schism, similar to the Great Western Schism, which will eventually end in a cleansing of the Church. As always, of course, there will always be some remnants left over from the "experiment," which will...

Apparently, it wasn't too obvious to many that the Pope was tasked with such a job. So, in order to remind people what this role is, de facto standardized what it is about rather than introducing something new. In order to be able to silence fruitless disputes in this way, with one decisive...

Okay schismatic, from what I saw. One Bishop of Rome, has done far more for Christendom than four patriachs combined. So maybe your way, is.... of no effect? So, maybe a church with one head presiding over the whole is just more effective? No, that's the whole point of the doctrine. It's just...

Me? The one who quotes smarter people than himself. They, in turn, note that in many places, Francis coincides with modernist tendencies, another heresy that has become popular among the more liberal members of the Church. What's more, his barely concealed hostility to Church tradition is plain...

On a good hunch, I would say that he would be brought before an ecclesiastical synod and eventually criminally removed from the throne and excluded from the church. If, of course, he does not disavow his erroneous theses, which I believe he will do but at the same time continue to muddy the...

He doesn't have to be bad, it's enough that he stumbles enough to find a reason to accuse him of modernist heresy. The problem is, however, that he is a very crafty man, doing evasions time and again when he seems close to defeat. So for the time being, one is left waiting for him to make a...

And that's what this dogma has been about from the very beginning! The Pope as successor to Christ's appointed confidant, St. Peter. He has the duty to guard the truthfulness of the faith and in any important dispute, by quoting Christ as he said it and not as some one made up to himself, to...

No, this is only due to a lack of explanation of what exactly papal infallibility consists of. It does not consist in the fact that the pope is infallible, it consists in the fact that the pope is infallible only in a certain way. If he transgresses this, he does something wrong. He is no...

Is this the first bad pope? No. Should I listen to him by virtue of infallibility? Also no! Because that is no longer covered by the dogma of infallibility! He is valid if and only if he teaches in a certain way, and in a way that is binding on the whole church. When he fails to meet even one...

Thanks I read, do you think I would have just walked in without knowing what it was about? You think why am I giving the idea that this discussion has become.... fruitless? Because what does the Pope's fallibility or lack thereof (which, by the way, is typical nonsense, exposing a lack of...

Because it is the truth? You don't understand and you're making excuses. Anyway, why do you assume I don't understand the point? I understand where the steorotype of the "ignorant" Catholic comes from, it's just that here you miss the point. I just see that the explanation is pointless in this...

I love to see a Protestant heretic arguing with an Orthodox schismatic about Catholic dogma. Truly, you guys got into a brilliant discussion. None of you are one, and you are concerned about it terribly. Why don't you go to your churches and argue from your positions? That will make a lot...