Search results

@Marduk.... I know you can't drop it, it seems to be an obsession, but really... I've asked you three times to stop talking to me. Stop now. Don't talk to me about this any more. I'm not engaging with your non-arguments anymore, you're being a hypocrite and you don't want to stop it, so further...

BUT MUH CONTINUITY OF STATES! It only applies when you want it to, huh? For real this time: let this be the end of the discussion.

Your rampant excuses now cross every line of logic. You asked for my general stance on governments, and now you try to make the whole debate about that. I must insist we put that "Ancap" matter aside: you are as obsessed about that as ATP is about Germany. You become deranged and fixated on it...

Nobody has asked you for reparations, @Marduk. So you're not being mistreated by Germany, under any rules. You're just an unrepentant looter, who wants to steal from young Germans for crimes committed by dead Germans, against Polish people who were not you. So I repeat myself: introspection...

What you're proposing is that the "new workers" in this comparison should have their personal bank accounts plundered by the company's management, so the management can pay its debts. For starters, that illustrates how immoral government is to begin with. But moreover, it illustrates how...

Then I suggest you seek out the members of the former government of the Third Reich, and/or those SS & military men who participated in the invasion and occupation, and you talk to them about any outstanding debts. They are the only ones who carry the responsibility for their own actions...

It is hardly a secret that I am a philosophical anarchist, and would prefer there to be no government at all. I recognise no authority over me, but that of the Almighty. But in a practical sense, I know this is not a realistic hope, so I tend to aim for the government that is least offensive to...

That's just desperate excuse-grasping. You're fixating on details to avoid engaging with the actual point, which is that "reparations" are inherently collctivist and therefore evil. Your excuse of "but THIS is living memory!" is just arbitrary. You're saying that it's all good to try to extort...

See? You are a communist, you think in collectives. "The state" is a fiction. In reality, the children and grandcildren have to pay-- which you already admitted is wrong. You're just being a hypocrite because you turn insane whenever anything involves Germany. Pure Germany Derangement Syndrome.

By your logic, the grand-children of a rape victim can demand payment from the grand-children of a rapist. Despite the fact that they themselves were never raped, the people they're trying to loot have never raped anyone, and neither of them were even alive when it happened. That's how insane...

As I stated to begin with: it's the exact same hypocrisy and truth-twisting that underpins all the "muh reparations!" movements. Thanks for proving that you're exactly like those BLM loonies when it comes to this matter. Except that instead of Trump Derangement Syndrome, it's... uh... Germany...

I see -- to my shocked surprise -- that communism still prevails in Poland. Collective guilt, as the name implies, is collectivism. In any event, I assume you'll be clamouring to restore the Imperial German borders immediately? That you support the expulsion of Poles from the relevant regions...

The "fat years" do tend to be the peaceful and complacent ones, yes. That's true everywhere. But as we both know, that brings its own problems, which then lead to a reversal. And of course, such a reversal isn't intrinsically bad, either. The slow death of stagnation is not a desirable fate; but...

If a Jew born in, say, 1980 demands that a German born that same year give him "reparations" for something that happened decades before either of them were born -- then he deserves a kick in the balls and a strong rejoinder to fuck off. If you never owned slaves, you don't owe anybody...

Present-day Poland deserves nothing from present-day Germany, in the same way that anyone whining about "reparations" deserves nothing. Reparation-whiners are the lowest of parasites; they were not alive during any of the events they whine about, yet they want to claim money from people who...