Planning a Hitler in WWI self-insert, who should he take over?

ATP

Well-known member
@PsihoKekec has beaten me to it when it comes to several points already. So I'll touch on those he hasn't.




Which it would be- this isn't the Russia of the 1940's. Russia in WW1 was much more backwards in its infrastructure. Plus, this isn't the mechanized Heer of WW2. And given the troubles they went though, it's doubtful that the German army of WW1 would be able to pull off the same job quickly when they're slower moving and are operating in even less of a developed Russia.

Furthermore, the idea that leaving the French off for later would be foolish. While the Sheliefen plan did fail in knocking out Frace from the War, it did ensure that most of the resource rich and industrialized parts of France ended up in German hands throughout the war.

And on a related subject-Belgium. And the British. As of 2014, we have a letter from King George to then Prime Minister Loyde George, basically telling him to find a way to get the Empire involved in the war against Germany. To make a long story short, the British were ALWAYS going to get involved in the war, regardless of if its people wanted to or not. Germany was too much of a challenge to them economically and becoming too powerful for the paranoid British to allow. Belgium was at best a convenient excuse.

On a final point- why are we picking Hitler? No seriously, why Hitler? He hated Imperial Germany and its leadership for not being raging manics like him and being nobility.

Also, the idea that Hitler would be able to blend in and impersonate whoever he's body jacking is laughable. He doesn't have the knowledge when it comes to the sort of environments or person. People would notice something is off and there's a fair bet he ends up in a sanitarium. Which is where he should have been at in the first place in our timeline.

Plus, Hitler had little actual military tactics or planning skills- most of his successes in WW2 came down to dumb luck, audacity and stealing other people's ideas and claiming they were his.

If the objective it to have the Central powers win WW1, there are a lot better choices for the job. Hell, give me a week to prepare and I could a better job.
All true,England formed coalitions to beat stronger european power since at least 1700.Considering that Russia after reforms becomed stronger,too,i bet that England after,let say,1925 would support germans,if there was no war.
And,in OTL,since 1919 they supported germans till 1938 against France.

Do not blame them for being smart.Like somebody during 7th year war said - England fight to the last prussian.
 

Agent23

Ни шагу назад!
Hitler in a Jew, that would be a fun one.
The Jew that invented poison gas and that was patriotic enough to sign the manifest of the 93, then build WWI Germany's chemical warfare program from scratch.
Guy was so hardcore that when his wife Minecrafted herself because of "muh perversions of science" in the form of chemical warfare, he was "well you do you" and went to the front to help the troops use his inventions.

Oh, and also he developed synthetic fertilizers, so most of humanity is alive and not starving because of him.

:cool:

Guy was based.

BASED!!!
 

King Arts

Well-known member
The Jew that invented poison gas and that was patriotic enough to sign the manifest of the 93, then build WWI Germany's chemical warfare program from scratch.
Guy was so hardcore that when his wife Minecrafted herself because of "muh perversions of science" in the form of chemical warfare, he was "well you do you" and went to the front to help the troops use his inventions.

Oh, and also he developed synthetic fertilizers, so most of humanity is alive and not starving because of him.

:cool:

Guy was based.

BASED!!!
Fritz Haber is definitely worthy of respect.
 

ATP

Well-known member
As I said, based.

Idiots like Hitler were basically claiming that people like him didn't exist and their antisemitism lost Germany lots of very, very good scientists.
Yes,jews loved germans,and could not undarstandt,why germans genocided them.My family passed stories how they waited for germans in 1939,becouse they belived,that they would behave like during WW1,when jews were wery well treatet.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top