• The Sietch will be brought offline for HPG systems maintenance tomorrow (Thursday, 2 May 2024). Please remain calm and do not start any interstellar wars while ComStar is busy. May the Peace of Blake be with you. Precentor Dune

Search results

  1. Terthna

    Philosophy Ethics of a real-life Butlerian Jihad

    You're welcome. For what it's worth, I don't think you're an "evil monster"; just incredibly misguided, from my perspective. That said, I suspect we'll be having arguments like this for as long as I'm a member of your forum. Ah well; agree to disagree?
  2. Terthna

    Philosophy Ethics of a real-life Butlerian Jihad

    To be honest, I feel the same way about you. I don't think we have a lot of ground in common, and I doubt we ever will. We're just too ideologically opposed to one another.
  3. Terthna

    Philosophy Ethics of a real-life Butlerian Jihad

    The heck is "post-Eclipse Pit"? Anyways; I don't really care what you believe. The facts just don't support your delusions.
  4. Terthna

    Philosophy Ethics of a real-life Butlerian Jihad

    Simple; because there has never been and never will be one contained by morality. The only thing that can is mutual self-interest. In short, the Landsraad era is a third-world dictatorship by today's standards, because the incentives of those in charge are aligned with very few of their...
  5. Terthna

    Philosophy Ethics of a real-life Butlerian Jihad

    Yeah, those "centuries of glory" were probably built atop a mountain of corpses; as they have usually been throughout human history. It is an assumption on my part, but going off of what was in the books; I'd rather be aborted in the machine era, than suffer in the post-machine era.
  6. Terthna

    Philosophy Ethics of a real-life Butlerian Jihad

    Do you honestly think you'd have any value in post-machine society in the Dune setting? Most of the factions would have treated you no better, outside of House Atreides; and we both know what happens to them eventually. Jehanna Butler fought for a world that held just as little regard for her...
  7. Terthna

    Philosophy Ethics of a real-life Butlerian Jihad

    Bullhonkey; I'd argue it's far, far worse. At least with automation, the human spirit isn't ground under the heels of competing totalitarian dictators, who are as ambitious as they are capricious; not to mention all the corpses such a system demands on a regular basis. If we did have an evil...
  8. Terthna

    Philosophy Ethics of a real-life Butlerian Jihad

    And then those men destroyed those machines, and decided to instead enslave themselves to these things: Yeah, that quote loses a lot of impact when you actually sit down and read Dune. The moral of the story is that men will always be slaves to other men; anything else is nothing more than an...
Top