What if Charles I won the English Civil War?

1.Corrupted democracy is no democracy but oligarchy,and there are no any real checks.And Oligarchies are no genociders,too - but they weak and aesy pray for any stronger country.Without possibility of any change from within which could save them.

Only oligarchy which lasted long was Venetia.All others falled,including Poland which fall quickly after oligarchs take over our Republic.

2.Louis could be stupid,and hugenot fate cruel - but compared what revolutions did,it was nothing.And oligarchs always led to that,becouse they are weak.
If Louis 16 treated his people like Louis 14,there would be no revolution. In other worlds - if he do not try stop be absolute monarch.

Tell that to Nicholas II of Russia. That's the mistake he made, as well as being a crap Czar. Similarly in WWI it was the constitutional monarchy in Britain and the republic in France that survived, not the autocratic states in Russia, Austria and Germany.

Or look at the history of China, Quite often dynasty's fade away over a long period of time but sometimes they don't last long. In which case its virtually always peasant unrest that is a big factor in their violent overthrow.

The treatment of the Huguenots were brutal and expanded over decades. However the point I think your missing was it occurred and lasted that long, with bad results for both them and France, because there was an autocratic monarchy would could get away with ignoring any warnings that "this is a bad idea sir". You see the same sort of thing with say Mao and Stalin as no one dare oppose them. With Hitler as well although his regime was so bad-shit insane that it only lasted just over a decade.

A corrupt democracy can act very similar to an oligarchy but it does have the chance of reform relatively easily, i.e. without the need for violent overthrowing of the current rulers. For instance the US has gotten rid of Trump despite many people being willing to break the law to maintain him. 30 years back Thatcher also feel when her irrationality was too much even for her party and the business interests that supported it, despite a terrible electoral system that enabled minority rule so long.
 
Tell that to Nicholas II of Russia. That's the mistake he made, as well as being a crap Czar. Similarly in WWI it was the constitutional monarchy in Britain and the republic in France that survived, not the autocratic states in Russia, Austria and Germany.

Or look at the history of China, Quite often dynasty's fade away over a long period of time but sometimes they don't last long. In which case its virtually always peasant unrest that is a big factor in their violent overthrow.

The treatment of the Huguenots were brutal and expanded over decades. However the point I think your missing was it occurred and lasted that long, with bad results for both them and France, because there was an autocratic monarchy would could get away with ignoring any warnings that "this is a bad idea sir". You see the same sort of thing with say Mao and Stalin as no one dare oppose them. With Hitler as well although his regime was so bad-shit insane that it only lasted just over a decade.

A corrupt democracy can act very similar to an oligarchy but it does have the chance of reform relatively easily, i.e. without the need for violent overthrowing of the current rulers. For instance the US has gotten rid of Trump despite many people being willing to break the law to maintain him. 30 years back Thatcher also feel when her irrationality was too much even for her party and the business interests that supported it, despite a terrible electoral system that enabled minority rule so long.

1.First Russian revolution happened,becouse tsar was loyal ally and not only do not agrred to peace,but also continued attacking germans to help France.
And soviets later win thanks to Wall Street and german moneys.

2.But China as Empire survived 3000 years.

3.Only stupid autocratic monarchs do not agree their advisors to speak freely - but they fall becouse of that stupidity,not becouse they are autocratic.

4.USA was not get rid of Trump thanks to democracy,but faked elections.Besides,Rhotbard book clearly show that from 1897 all elected presidents was creatures of Wall Street,becouse they simply made system in which to become candidate for Republican or Democratic party,you must be Wall Street creature.
Trump was backed by smarter part of bankster elite,and overthrown by stupid ones.That is all.
Do not think that political theater is real.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top