WI: Franco Assassinated, 1948

History Learner

Well-known member
In September of 1948, Spanish Anarchist exiles-including former members of the French Resistance-attempted to assassinate the Spanish Caudillo by bombing his fishing boat via air. Obviously, this attempt failed and Franco would go on to live until 1975, but what if it hadn't? What if Franco had died then; how would Francoist Spain develop from there?

Unlike OTL 1975, Luis Carrero Blanco is still alive and he is the natural successor that Franco wanted. So the succession is relatively easy, although a Carlist King is likely to be crowned sometime in the 1950s as there is no Unification Degree by Franco and associated purges of Royalists. Until that point the Carlists, since the 1930s, had been extremely powerful and influential, with a strong financial base, armed wing, and youth as well as women's groups; this would also help to give the regime more legitimacy and secure a power base for it, instead of leaving it increasingly as just a personality cult dedicated solely to Franco.

Economics is, however, much trickery to speculate upon. For one, I don't know what Blanco thought about Franco's economic policies, with the latter only moving from autarky in 1956. Doing so in 1948 is obviously better for not just the regime but also for Spain at large, because by the OTL 1960s Spain was absolutely booming to the extent it was speculated that Fascism would make a come-back based upon the success of the Spanish Model:

The biggest success was the acquisition of needed capital. The end of autarky brought in roughly $8 billion worth of foreign direct investment. Increased tourism, twenty million visitors came to Spain, and remittances from abroad supplied funds for needed capital goods. The new policies and flood of money into Spain from abroad fueled a fifteen-year growth in the economy, from $12 billion to $76 billion, that was surpassed only by Japan.​
The economic transformation was so powerful that some thought it gave fascism a new lease on life. In an October 7, 1968 editorial entitled “Fascism for the Future,” the American historian Gabriel Jackson speculated that fascism would outlive Franco. As he wrote, “a Fraquist type of dictatorship may continue for decades in Spain and by doing so may provide a model for other nations that achieve a minimum of economic prosperity in the absence of strong traditions of political liberty.”​

To get an idea of how much of an effect no autarky and earlier Marshall Aid funding would have:
This article uses historical fact as a natural experiment to measure a country’s welfare loss from shifting from an allowed to a restricted trade situation, based on international trade theory. A welfare loss of 8 per cent of GDP is found. The evolution of domestic import and export prices in Spain in 1940–58 fits international trade theory assumptions. The main years of autarky are not those commonly considered, but 1947–55, marked by the exclusion of Spain from the Marshall Plan and the Madrid Treaty between Franco’s regime and the US. The upper-bound welfare loss for 1947–55 is 26 per cent of GDP.

A booming Spain from the late 1940s on, instead of a late start in the 1960s, might be sufficient to place it firmly on the same level as the UK or France; i.e. a $2 Trillion + economy. I wouldn't be surprised if "Francoist" Spain is able to last until the present given this, in the same way the PRC has outlived the collapse of Global Communism. The question is, however, whether the support/political ability to do such was there, by Blanco and the various factions in the regime.
 
If a Carlist king is chosen - IIRC the Carlist claimant Xavier's heir, Carlos Hugo, turned out to be some bizarre monarcho-Titoist, wasn't he? Pretty much the polar opposite of what normally comes to mind when I hear the word 'Carlist'. Seems like such a political evolution could complicate Spanish politics massively in the '70s if it isn't butterflied away, or Blanco/a successor decides to circumvent the problem by getting Carlos Hugo out of the way (one way or another) & punting the crown to his brother Sixtus (who, from what little I've read about him, seems to have been a normal traditionalist Carlist).

Anyway, I imagine a Carlist-ruled Francoist Spain (minus Carlos Hugo) would have an easy time cultivating good relations with Opus Dei, whose members (chiefly Alberto Ullastres) were already among the most important ministers who engineered Spain's economic miracle IOTL. Maybe Opus Dei can actually form a lasting political party or faction in Spain at some point?
 
While I don't think Spain would get that much money from USA, due to not being bombed into oblivion during WWII, the American technical assistance could have a huge impact on Spanish industry, perhaps some of it would be entrenched enough to survive the othervise devastating entry into EU.
 
If a Carlist king is chosen - IIRC the Carlist claimant Xavier's heir, Carlos Hugo, turned out to be some bizarre monarcho-Titoist, wasn't he? Pretty much the polar opposite of what normally comes to mind when I hear the word 'Carlist'. Seems like such a political evolution could complicate Spanish politics massively in the '70s if it isn't butterflied away, or Blanco/a successor decides to circumvent the problem by getting Carlos Hugo out of the way (one way or another) & punting the crown to his brother Sixtus (who, from what little I've read about him, seems to have been a normal traditionalist Carlist).

Anyway, I imagine a Carlist-ruled Francoist Spain (minus Carlos Hugo) would have an easy time cultivating good relations with Opus Dei, whose members (chiefly Alberto Ullastres) were already among the most important ministers who engineered Spain's economic miracle IOTL. Maybe Opus Dei can actually form a lasting political party or faction in Spain at some point?

Carlos Hugo's father staked his claim to the throne as Javier I in 1952, so presumably he would be King first followed by Carlos Hugo when the former dies. A quick glance at Wikipedia seems to suggest he made his Left turn in the 1960s, so perhaps that could be avoided or re-molded into Falangism given his differing circumstances? What's your take?

While I don't think Spain would get that much money from USA, due to not being bombed into oblivion during WWII, the American technical assistance could have a huge impact on Spanish industry, perhaps some of it would be entrenched enough to survive the othervise devastating entry into EU.

As weird as it may sound, after the spigots finally turned on in the 1950s, Spain ended up getting more U.S. aid than anybody sans France or the UK. Most of the reason for the delay was lingering World War II hostility as well as the death of the FDR-again, weird-because the latter had promised Franco in private that his continued neutrality would be rewarded Post-War. As with many things, Truman hadn't been informed of that and ultimately it took until the Eisenhower years and the Second Red Scare to let Franco get funding.
 
Carlos Hugo's father staked his claim to the throne as Javier I in 1952, so presumably he would be King first followed by Carlos Hugo when the former dies. A quick glance at Wikipedia seems to suggest he made his Left turn in the 1960s, so perhaps that could be avoided or re-molded into Falangism given his differing circumstances? What's your take?
Yep, that was one outcome I suggested in my previous post - with at least 10 years' worth of butterflies, it might be possible for Carlos Hugo to remain an 'orthodox' Carlist or at least pick another ideology that isn't so blatantly offensive to traditional Carlist principles. Even becoming a normal democrat like Juan Carlos would've been less strange than attempting a synthesis of Carlism and Titoism of all things.

In any case, if Carlos Hugo is still the same as his OTL self I doubt Carrero Blanco or any other dictator needs to actually kill him to get him out of the way - they could just pressure him to abdicate in favor of his brother or son, if butterflies don't also eliminate the latter's birth. He did give up his claims and on politics entirely in 1979 historically after all. And if he does change to be a normal Carlist, that'd logically mean smoother relations with the enduring Francoist regime.

One more interesting possibility related to Carlist dynastic woes: maybe Carrero Blanco doesn't need to pick the main Carlist branch of Bourbon-Parma to be king at all. Apparently there was a movement to put a Habsburg branch with Carlist blood ties on the throne, and they had excellent relations with the Francoists (indeed from a cursory reading it seems they got a lot of the Carlists disappointed by Xavier's unwillingness to collaborate with said Francoists to the maximum extent) to the point that Franco might've genuinely considered enthroning them over said main branch in the late 1940s. So...maybe a Spanish Habsburg restoration to circumvent whatever mess might come with Carlos Hugo, perhaps?
 
Yep, that was one outcome I suggested in my previous post - with at least 10 years' worth of butterflies, it might be possible for Carlos Hugo to remain an 'orthodox' Carlist or at least pick another ideology that isn't so blatantly offensive to traditional Carlist principles. Even becoming a normal democrat like Juan Carlos would've been less strange than attempting a synthesis of Carlism and Titoism of all things.
Well Tito was often described as monarchist in communist clothing, so someone who became his fan could also become a die hard absolutist if given a taste of power.
 
Well Tito was often described as monarchist in communist clothing, so someone who became his fan could also become a die hard absolutist if given a taste of power.
But Carlists were not absolutists - they fought in the name of traditional monarchy.Which would survive to our time,saving Spain and maybe Portugal.Unless King become second Tito - then it would fall just like in OTL.
Surviving normal Spain could save Poland - there were Radio Madrid in polish till 1975,and we could have monarchist in 1989,leftist would still rule,but not as long as in OTL,and inmstead of socialist Kaczyński we could have King now.
They could save Portugal african colonies if Portugal go left,too.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top