Star Wars Lightsaber Lethality (Spoilers for Ahsoka)

posh-goofiness

Well-known member
I mean...Qui Gonn Jinn was also a Jedi MASTER. It's likely that he was using the Force to minimize damage in some way and try and heal himself in some form of Jedi Trance. However, the damage was too severe for him to overcome without add'l aid...which he didn't get in time.
Yeah, in Legends it's this ability.
 

Bear Ribs

Well-known member
hot take: This feat of the lightsaber melting the blast door is actually an outlier feat compared to other showings even within the prequels themselves in most circumstances a lightsaber is less a blade of molten hot plasma and more a thousand-degree sword, with most of it's damage reflecting that. Heck in the fight between Obi-Wan and Dooku, Dooku cuts both Obi-Wan's arm and leg leaving about as much damage as an actual sword cut albeit cauterized,. Meaning, if one could imagine surviving a sword strike, surviving a lightsaber strike, is not as farfetched as one might think.
Going on with this theme, it's worth noting that Ponda Baba's arm was bleeding after Obi-Wan cut it off in the Mos Eisley Cantina. So if we take earlier as better, in the OT Lightsabers aren't even necessarily hot enough to cauterize an arm. During the sail barge fight, we can also see that Jabba's henchmen are reacting more like they were hit with a bat. We see multiple guys take full-on hits only to be knocked back, completely intact as if not even taking a cut. So in the OT, lightsabers really didn't have that much cutting power or heat at all.



 

ThatZenoGuy

Zealous Evolutionary Nano Organism
Comrade
Yeah light sabers aren't supposed to cauterize wounds because, as always intended due to Gerorge Lucas' fascination with Japanese (and WW2) movies, they're space-katanas.
They're more like 40k Power weapons, but I don't see why they cannot have a 'heat up area being sliced' mode given that they are big energy blades.
 
Going on with this theme, it's worth noting that Ponda Baba's arm was bleeding after Obi-Wan cut it off in the Mos Eisley Cantina. So if we take earlier as better, in the OT Lightsabers aren't even necessarily hot enough to cauterize an arm. During the sail barge fight, we can also see that Jabba's henchmen are reacting more like they were hit with a bat. We see multiple guys take full-on hits only to be knocked back, completely intact as if not even taking a cut. So in the OT, lightsabers really didn't have that much cutting power or heat at all.




Even in the before time (During the prequels long before even Disney Star wars even facebook and twitter) there was a joke among star wars fans that lightsabers were as powerful as the scene/plot demanded it'd be.
I hate it when people use the whole Qui-gon melting the blastdoors scene as the go-to feat for how powerful a lightsaber is/should be and how all of these other instances are the result of outliers/bad writing when The reality is no lightsabers were not meant to be that power and the blast doors scene was the feat that was inconsistent. I can count on one hand how many times it's been done even in extended material, and of course, there is a question of, if lightsabers are so hot they can melt steel like butter,

1. How is anybody even able to wield them without getting at best 1st degree burns?
2. Why do Anakin and Obi-wan have to rely on droids and hacking computer systems to open blast doors when they have a weapon that can double as a skeleton key?

now don't get me wrong having sabine recovering in a hospital bed was still cringe, at the very least we should have gotten a scene of her floating in a bacta tanka ala Luke in ESB, but I don't think lightsabers are the instant molten blades of death that some fans especially modern ones, make them out to be.
 

ATP

Well-known member
i remember lightsaber duel from Tenchi Muyo GP,where villain is defeated but not killed,becouse good one hit him with flat side of lightsaber....
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top