United States Supreme Court Watch

FAQs and how to 'watch' SCOTUS on opinion day
  • Figured I'd add this as well, but a quick guide to release days (the next one is tomorrow):

    The Supreme Court does not release all their opinions at once. Instead, beginning at 10AM EST on an opinion day, the most junior member with a controlling opinion (usually a majority, sometimes the plurality, rarely something else) to release that day reads out their opinion. As they begin to read it, it's posted simultaneously to the Scotus's website, here abouts. This continues from most junior to most senior (with the Chief Justice always going last regardless of seniority).

    So how many opinions will be announced? No one outside the court knows until it happens, but we have a few clues. 2 key things are the number of boxes, which is how many boxes were needed to transport the printed off opinions. Note that it's not a perfect indicator, as a long opinion might take almost all of a box, or a short one hardly any. Second is what's called an R-Number. Basically each opinion has a number. Sometimes that number ends with an R. If it does, that's the last opinion to be released that day.

    How do you know how many boxes are there, and how to get a link to the opinion and know which side won? SCOTUSblog.com has main page live updates on every opinion day, with commenters noting the number of boxes ahead of time, and keeping people updated re: what opinion just got decided, a link to the opinion, and what was decided.

    More FAQ stuff here:
     
    Last edited:
    2024 Upcoming Major Decisions
  • NRA v Vullo (about if the NRA was discriminated against by NY State, violating the First Amendment) (Answer: Yes)
    US v Rahimi (Do domestic violence restraining orders removing gun rights violate 2A? This is not a case we'd like to see before SCOTUS.) (Answer: No, but Bruen still holds, so a very minor loss).
    Garland v Cargill (Bumpstock Ban) (Answer: the ATF can't redefine the definition of Machine gun at will. Bump stock ban overturned.)
    Relentless v Department of Commerce (Should the Chevron Doctrine be overruled?) The most important case this term. Chevron Doctrine (AKA Chevron Deference) is current legal precedent that administrative agencies get to decide how to interpret the law affecting them instead of a court. (Answer: Yes, no more Chevron!)
    Murphy v Missouri (did government action make social media a government actor? I don't think this is going to be a yes from SCOTUS, sadly) (Answer: Doesn't matter, standing failed. Try again with another case entirely.)
    Moyle v US (Is Idaho's Defense of Life act preempted by federal law?) (Answer: Punted via DIG, try again).

    Not decided yet:
    Trump v US (The Trump Federal Immunity Case)
    A few NetChoice cases (about the first amendment, and can you force companies to have content neutral moderation?)


    I'll probably clean this up later.
     
    Last edited:
    Back
    Top